Ingredient Substitutes for Indian Cooking: What to Use When You Run Out

Halfway through a recipe and out of curd, cream or Eno? Most Indian ingredients have a swap that works, as long as you know how much to use and which dishes it suits. Here are the substitutions Siddhi reaches for, grouped by what they do in a recipe.

A swap changes a dish a little, so treat these as fixes for when you’ve run out, not as replacements for the real thing every time.

Dairy swaps

Out ofUse insteadWorks best in
Fresh cream (1/2 cup)1/4 cup cashews soaked and ground with 1/4 cup milkGravies like paneer butter masala
Fresh cream for richness3 tbsp milk + 1 tbsp melted butter, added off the flameSoups and dals
Buttermilk (1 cup)1/4 cup curd whisked with 3/4 cup waterKadhi, chaas, batters
Hung curdThick curd strained in a cloth for 2 hoursDips, kebabs, shrikhand
Sour curd for battersFresh curd + 1 tsp lemon juiceDhokla, handvo, rava idli
GheeButter, or oil for temperingTadka and parathas (not sweets)
Condensed milk (1/2 cup)1 cup milk + 1/4 cup sugar, simmered until reduced by halfKheer, kulfi, fudge

Siddhi’s guides to making hung curd and thickening milk without khoya cover the longer versions of these swaps.

Sour and sweet swaps

Out ofUse insteadWorks best in
Tamarind paste (1 tsp)1/2 tsp amchur, or 1 tsp lemon juice added at the endSambar, chutneys, sabzi
Amchur (1 tsp)1 to 2 tsp lemon juice, added off the flameDry sabzi, chaat, tikkis
KokumTamarind or a little lemon juiceDal, kadhi, sol kadhi
JaggeryBrown sugar (a little less sweet in flavour)Dal, chutneys, chikki
Powdered sugarRegular sugar ground fine in a dry mixer jarLadoos, shrikhand, icing

Raising agents

Out ofUse insteadWorks best in
Eno fruit salt (1 tsp)1/2 tsp baking soda + 1 tsp lemon juice, added just before steamingDhokla, idli, handvo
Baking powder (1 tsp)1/4 tsp baking soda + 1/2 tsp lemon juice or 1/4 cup curdCakes, muffins, pancakes

Soda and lemon start bubbling as soon as they meet, so mix them into the batter at the last moment and get it straight into the steamer or oven. See Siddhi’s khaman dhokla for how it’s done.

Spice and aromatic swaps

Out ofUse insteadWorks best in
Fresh ginger (1 tsp grated)1/4 tsp dry ginger powder (saunth)Chai, dal, gravies
Ginger-garlic paste (1 tbsp)1/2 tsp each of ginger and garlic powderGravies, marinades
Garam masala (1 tsp)A pinch each of cinnamon, clove and cardamom powderCurries, pulao
Kasuri methiLeave it out; there’s no true swapPaneer gravies
Curry leavesLeave them out; a few coriander stems add freshnessTempering
Kashmiri chilli powderHalf the amount of regular chilli powder + 1/2 tsp paprika for colourGravies, tandoori

Siddhi’s guide to the spices in her kitchen explains what each spice does, which helps when deciding whether to swap or skip.

Flour and thickener swaps

Out ofUse insteadWorks best in
Cornflour (for thickening)The same amount of arrowroot, or a little rice flourSoups, Indo-Chinese gravies
Rice flour (for crispness)Cornflour or fine soojiPakoda and vada batters
Bread crumbsCrushed cornflakes, sooji or roasted pohaCutlets and kebabs
Coconut milk (1 cup)1/4 cup fresh coconut ground with 3/4 cup warm water and strained, or cashew paste with milkCurries, stews

For coating ideas, see how to bind, shape and coat cutlets and kebabs.

When not to swap

  • Besan in dhokla, kadhi and pakodas has no real substitute.
  • Chhena or paneer in rasgulla and sandesh must be fresh; store-bought paneer won’t work.
  • Baking: swaps change texture more than in cooking. Stick to the recipe for your first try.

For measurements while you swap, see Indian kitchen measures, and for rescuing a dish that went wrong, see kitchen fixes.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top